The Vatican’s Spiritual Violence Against Women’s Ordination By Rosemary Radford Ruether

The Vatican has adopted what amounts to a “zero tolerance” policy against those Catholics who actively advocate for women’s ordination, particularly against anyone involved in the movement of Roman Catholic Womenpriests which, for the past three years, has ordained thirty-five women in the United States. This movement began in June, 2002, when seven women were ordained by some Catholic bishops in Austria. Later several of these women were ordained bishops by these same bishops. They, in turn, have ordained more women priests. From this has sprung an increasingly organized movement, which is developing the theological vision of church which they hope to generate and are laying down the formal rubrics for education and preparation for ministry of those aspiring to be ordained in their community.

The Vatican summarily excommunicated the initial seven women ordained in 2002. As more women were ordained it was at first silent and then decreed that anyone being ordained in this movement, as well as those supporting it, were automatically excommunicated. This saved them the trouble of addressing each of these women individually. However, they have escalated their campaign against women’s ordination in the last month in response to Maryknoll priest, Father Roy Bourgeois, who on August 9, 2008 in Lexington, Kentucky, concelebrated the mass where long-time friend, Sevre-Duszynska, was ordained. Father Bourgeois also preached the homily at this ordination mass, where he denounced the Church’s refusal to ordain women as a sin comparable to the sin of racism. “Sexism is a sin” he declared.

In late October Father Bourgeois received a letter from the Vatican through his Maryknoll Superiors, giving him thirty days to recant his position on women’s ordination or be excommunicated. Bourgeois refused to recant and has instead reiterated his view that his support of women’s ordination is a matter of unshakable conscience. For Bourgeois it is clear that that the Vatican is profoundly in error on this question of rejecting the ordination of women. Catholic Biblical studies have shown that there is no valid case to be made against the ordination of women from the Scriptures. Rather this rejection reflects fundamentally a sinful prejudice against women similar to traditions that believed that Blacks were inferior and should sit in the back pews of the church. It is the Vatican that needs to recant of this sinful prejudice and accept that it is God who is calling women to be ordained.

Bourgeois has also pointed out the harshness of the Vatican’s response to women’s ordination, in contrast to their slowness to take a strong stand against priests who abused children. Apparently the Vatican takes the sexual abuse of children by priests much less seriously than the challenge coming from those who disagree with their rejection of women’s call to ordained ministry. These women’s “sin” is that they wish to serve the church in proclaiming the gospel and celebrating the sacraments. Why is the Vatican so hostile to women’s call to ministry in a church clearly suffering from a vast deficit in adequate numbers of priests to pastor the people of God? How can it construe women seeking to minister in the church, and those who support it, as such a threat to its institutional order that they should be cut off from the sacraments of the church? Such a response to this movement and its supporters is nothing less than acts of spiritual violence, the equivalent of an effort to “kill” someone with whom one disagrees, to declare them spiritually dead and not in communion with God.

Why is the Vatican so threatened by this movement of women priests? One issue is that this movement is standing in judgment on the Vatican’s rejection of women’s ordination as both theologically in error and morally sinful, rooted in fundamental hostility to women as full human beings equally made in God’s  image and capable of representing Christ as priest. If the Vatican’s teachings are wrong on this, then its claim to infallible authority is in question. Infallibility itself is an error that needs to be recanted. But the authority issue is simply the institutional façade that is in jeopardy with any challenge to any teaching. Bourgeois I think is right in recognizing that the deep roots of this rejection are indeed sexism, a fundamental unwillingness to acknowledge women’s equal humanity, an unwillingness that lurks behind all the romanticism about women’s “difference.”


Like Father Bourgeois I think Christians today of all traditions, but specifically Catholics, need to see this issue as non-negotiable. We need to insist on women’s capacity for ordained ministry and the validity of their call to such ministry by God. This means that we need to continue to pursue parallel paths to women’s ordination as long at the Vatican refuses to acknowledge the truthfulness of this claim. We will not be deterred by escalating blows of spiritual violence from the Vatican. As long as we are firm in our convictions, such blows finally cannot harm us. This perhaps is the deepest fear of the Vatican, to recognize that its most powerful weapons against this dissent are finally impotent.

Rosemary Radford Ruether, Ph.D. is Professor of Feminist Theology at Claremont Graduate University and Claremont School of Theology.  She is also the Carpenter Emerita Professor of Feminist Theology at Pacific School of Religion and the GTU, as well as the Georgia Harkness Emerita Professor of Applied Theology at Garrett Evangelical Theological Seminary. Rosemary has enjoyed a long and distinguished career as a scholar, teacher, and activist in the Roman Catholic Church, and is well known as a groundbreaking figure in Christian feminist theology.  Ruether is the author of multiple articles and books including Sexism and God-TalkGaia and GodWomen Healing Earth and The Wrath of Jonah: The Crisis of Religious Nationalism in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. Her most recent books include Catholic Does Not Equal the Vatican: A Vision for Progressive Catholicism(2008), Many Forms of Madness: A Family’s Struggle with Mental Illness(2010), and Women and Redemption: A Theological History, 2nd ed.(2011).


Categories: Catholic Church, Major Feminist Thinkers in Religion, Rosemary Radford Ruether, Women and Ministry, Women's Ordination

Tags: , , , , , , ,

8 replies

  1. Yeah, Rosemary!!! We can always count on you to “tell it like it is”!!!


  2. The ordination of women joins a long list of aberrant church policies that have been “dressed up” (couldn’t pass up the pun) as not only theology but now dogma. Look at the RC church’s position on gays and lesbians and its vociferous attack on this community. I tried for years to “make sense” of this insane belief system. Of course, this is not of God but the sinfulness of a church locked away by those who should lead.

    What I did and what I recommend others to consider is join the independent Catholic movement. Since the 1850s, independent Catholicism has offered RC Catholics a credible, sacramental alternative to the insanity of the institutional church.

    Check out the American National Catholic Church, a contemporary expression of our ancient catholic tradition. For more information, check out our website:

    Warmly –

    Bill Freeman
    Director of Communications and Development
    American National Catholic Church


  3. Beautiful double-entendre at the end there.


  4. Thanks for sharing Bill, I was not aware of the American National Catholic Movement. Very interesting, I am definitely going to look into it.


  5. I have no idea why someone who is not even a Christian (which is obvious looking at the content of some of her books) is even interested in pursuing this topic. I’m not a catholic, but I reckon you should either become a catholic or cease to try changing this institution to suit your ignoble agenda. No one is forced to belong to the catholic church anymore. If they wnat to be a minister, leave and go somewhere else.


  6. Wow, Matt…the exclusion of women from the priesthood is clearly a social justice issue. Why should women have to leave the Catholic Church because some choose to actively oppress them? Surely we haven’t ended other social injustices by simply quitting. This situation is no different. As Ruether asserts in the title of one of her books – the Vatican does not equal Catholicism. We all have a duty to stand up to oppression wherever we see it – and certainly that is what is happening here.


  7. I may be a bit out of date here, and definitely out of order, in commenting on the ire invoked by the vexing question of women priests. For one thing, to apply the word priest to a woman is insulting in the extreme. I do not want to be a priest, thank you very much. I do not have a penis and neither do I want one. I will be a priestess – or nothing. Ay, and there’s the rub! Priestess! What a wonderful word, what power (try on yourselves, my sisters, and feel the resonance as the frisson of unconsciously embedded patriarchal fear and displeasure gradually leaves you) what wondrous imagery – She, Ourante the Open Armed Holy Mary – is unleashed in our cellular memory. What fear the word priestess engenders. Why? Why indeed. When we clear that little backlog of prejudice we may be able to approach the real question of women in the pulpit. So for me the question is purely academic. Until we stand together to make our stand at the pulpit as Priestesses, the debate is hollow. By “allowing” women vicars, reverends, etc the Protestant churches, to the last, are simply refusing to change the very fabric of the patriarchy they protect so assiduously. And the women who stand in their pulpits spout from the standard patriarchal texts. Nope, I shall continue to talk to the cathedral trees and to Holy Mary, without the boys. Zoé


Please familiarize yourself with our Comment Policy before posting.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: