What Feminists of Color Taught Me In the Wake of the Michael Brown Shooting by Grace Yia-Hei Kao


Like many others, I’ve been following the aftermath of the recent shooting death of an 18-year old black teenager by a police officer in Ferguson, Missouri with a mixture of shock and horror. Mainstream news coverage and my Facebook newsfeed have been appropriately flooded with commentary about systemic racism, racial profiling, civil unrest, and the militarization of the police. As several African American thought leaders have noted, Brown’s death was not an aberration but “just the most recent example of police officers killing unarmed black men.”

I probably would have only continued to think about these horrific black-male-deaths-by-white-police accounts through these familiar lenses of racism, police brutality, parental grief, and communal protest had I not stumbled upon several

Xochitl Alvizo; Photo by http://www.chrispinkham.com/

Xochitl Alvizo; Photo by http://www.chrispinkham.com

reflections explicitly identifying Michael Brown’s shooting death as a feminist issue. Xochitl Alvizo, for one, analogized between the “everyday existence of young black men, of boys in this country, and that of women” (viz., “the lack of safety in public places; the need to always be aware of one’s surroundings; the lack of trust in the intentions of another; living with the knowledge that people like you experience violence at much higher rates than others”). While any astute observer could have made this comparison, I’m not surprised that it was a queer feminist of color (Latina) who did so in this case.

 

Other feminists of color, including Dani McClain of The Nation, senior legal analyst Imani Gandy as quoted in Feminist Newswire, and Emma Akpan of RH Reality Check, explicitly named police violence against black and brown male youth as a “reproductive justice” concern in a way that I had not heretofore considered.

 

According to Loretta Ross, co-founder and National Coordinator of the SisterSong Women of Color Reproductive Justice Collective from 2005-2012, the term SisterSong“reproductive justice” was coined by African American women in 1994 after the International Conference on Population and Development in Cairo, Egypt. While widely adopted and used by activists, academics, funders and others alike, the term is “not merely a substitute for the terms ‘pro-choice,’ ‘reproductive rights,’ or even ‘sexual rights.’” Instead, the framework is at once intersectional and holistic in seeking to go beyond the narrow “it’s my body, it’s my choice” language in attending to the harsh realities that disproportionately  block underprivileged women of color from self-determination in crucial aspects of their lives. As black feminist activist Jasmine Burnett explains, “We look at the right to have a child, to not have a child, and to parent your child in a safe and sustainable community free from violence….If you aren’t safe in your community because you’re racially profiled by the police, and you can’t walk from your home to a clinic or to a hospital to access the services you need, then that’s not really a full articulation of reproductive justice.”

 

More specifically, the shooting death of Michael Brown (and others) violates the third of the three core reproductive justice principles for which SisterSong has stood since their founding in 1997:

  • Decide if and when she will have a baby and the conditions under which she will give birth
  • Decide if she will not have a baby and her options for preventing or ending a pregnancy
  • Parent the children she already has with the necessary social supports in safe environments and healthy communities, and without fear of violence from individuals or the government
Huy Mach, hmach@post-dispatch.com. caption: Lesley McSpadden is comforted by her husband, Louis Head, after her 18-year-old son was shot and killed by police earlier in the afternoon in the 2900 block of Canfield Drive on Saturday, Aug. 9, 2014, in Ferguson. Head is the step-father.

Photo by Huy Mach, hmach@post-dispatch.com. Caption: Lesley McSpadden is comforted by her husband, Louis Head after her 18-year-old son was shot and killed by police earlier in the afternoon in the 2900 block of Canfield Drive on Saturday, Aug. 9, 2014, in Ferguson.

This lesser emphasized third principle among those committed to reproductive rights seems entirely appropriate to me—a helpful corrective to the mistaken view that all that is needed on this front is legal, safe, and affordable access to reproductive healthcare for women. It both angers and saddens me to read of accounts from black feminists like Akpan that they “grew up listening to woman saying, oh Lord, I’m having a son, I’ll have to protect him from the police.” As an Asian American who gave birth to two half-Asian, half-white boys, I’ve not had the same fears. Because of the work of these feminists of color, I will now add these “feminist” and “reproductive justice” angles to the many ways I’m processing the news in Ferguson, MO. I encourage readers of this blog to do so as well.

 

Grace Yia-Hei Kao is Associate Professor of Ethics at Claremont School of Theology. She is the author of Grounding Human Rights in a Pluralist World (Georgetown University Press, 2011) and her co-edited anthology with Ilsup Ahn on Asian American Christian Ethics is forthcoming (with Baylor University Press). She is also co-editing a volume with Rebecca Todd Peters that is tentatively entitled “Encountering the Sacred: A Theological Exploration of Women’s Lives.” Read more about her work on her website.



Categories: Abuse of Power, Activism, Racism, Reproductive Justice, Social Justice

Tags: , , , , , ,

12 replies

  1. Thank you for your thorough and questioning blog… I am a white Mother and Grandmother of children of mixed ethnicity and understand both the experience of my son being racially profiled by police and the fears that face women (including white women) daily that seem to grow expedientially in contemporary US society. It is a long journey to process or to overcome the pain of rearing a child who is taken away so heartlessly and needlessly. You article and this child’s death has brought up the remembrance of old questions not really gone away.

    Like

  2. What Is a ‘Women’s Issue’? Do women have an instinct to care for others, is it built into our gender? I don’t known for sure, but It seems to me all suffering is our issue and our outreach, any place, any time, in any form.

    Like

  3. Thanks, Grace, for this post. The reproductive justice lens for viewing the issue of racial profiling/police violence against African-American men brings home this violence to anyone who has ever loved a child.

    Like

  4. Hi Grace,
    Thank you for this post. I have read articles dealing with “Reproductive Justice” before– but not put in those terms. I really appreciate this language with which to talk about this and research it more.

    Last year in my “Sexual Ethics” class we read an article about the way in which unilateral support for all birth control in some feminist organizations has failed to consider the ways that more dangerous forms of birth control are tested on and distributed to women in the 2/3 world and global south. It definitely challenges readers to consider how support of a ‘right’ must critically consider the co-optation of a discourse of ‘rights’ in neo-colonial and racist agendas. … I have been doing a lot of research on this idea lately.

    I had not considered this sad murder in terms of Reproductive Justice either; and this is an important way of viewing the situation– thank you for sharing what you learned here.

    Like

    • Thanks for writing, Sara, and for sharing what you covered in your class. You are right that these issues are complex and that we must hold together feminist commitments with anti-racist work alongside of other bioethical concerns like informed consent, protection of vulnerable populations, etc.

      Sent from my iPhone

      >

      Like

Trackbacks

  1. Does the Term “Women of Color” Bother You? By Grace Yia-Hei Kao | Dr. Grace Kao
  2. Does the Term “Women of Color” Bother You? | Dr. Grace Kao

Please familiarize yourself with our Comment Policy before posting.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: