An Algorithm for Capturing White Heteropatriarchy: The Woman Caught in Adultery and the Failure of the Civil Rights and Feminist Movements to Embrace Intersectionality by Blanche Cook


 

The church occasioned one of my first conscious experiences with inequality — Sunday school to be exact. I was nine and bedecked in black platform shoes and a bright pink polyester suit.  It was the 70s, a moment in fashion history never to be revisited.  My Sunday school teacher, a spiritually angelic woman, was explaining the demise of the Woman Caught in Adultery. According to the story, the leaders of law and religion wanted to stone the woman to death for having intercourse with a man that was not her husband.  Although she was vulnerable to the death penalty, the man was not exposed to any punishment.  This lopsided sanctioning plagued my young mind.  Little did I know, I would spend my legal career, as a federal sex trafficking prosecutor and as a legal scholar, trying to vindicate the Woman Caught in Adultery.

 

Punishing the woman for a crime that both the woman and a man committed stood outside the political atmosphere or Zeitgeist of the moment, specifically the Black Power and Feminist movements.  The unevenness of treatment, rampant inequality, and inability to detect criminality in the body of the “oppressor,” and only the “oppressed,” ignited both movements.  It was the 70’s, after all.  Although the Civil Rights, Black Power, and Feminist movements expanded during my youth, none fully embraced the work of the other or an intersectional agenda – possibly explaining the current political moment.  Perhaps, the current political climate reflects a failure of the popular political movements of the 60’s and 70’s to embrace Intersectionality, an understanding that racism, sexism, and classism not only overlap, but that each supports and sustains the work of the other.  Had the feminist movement, for example, fully embraced Intersectionality, might it have acknowledged that the killing of Trayvon Martin could explain the rise of President Donald Trump? Or, that the demonization of black men as the prototype for criminality immunizes the treachery of majority men from detection?  If, for example, multiple women had accused President Barak Obama of sexual assault and that he had conspired with a foreign country to steal the presidential election, can there be any doubt that we would be embroiled in impeachment proceedings this minute?

 

When the Ted organization (the “Teddies”) contacted me to do a Ted Talk, I initially thought it was a joke.  When I asked them how they found me, they said that Wayne State University Law School had publicized its most recent addition to the law school faculty, a former federal prosecutor specializing in large-scale sex and drug trafficking prosecutions.  I knew the Teddies were looking for a talk about sex trafficking.  Like for example, how we are all complicit in creating a sex trafficking culture, one that encourages the sexual objectification of vulnerability or one that actively creates vulnerability for purposes of sexual exploitation. When I told the Teddies that I wanted to build an algorithm to capture white heteropatriarchal power or racism, sexism, and classism, using the parable of the Woman Caught In Adultery, they were equally as spellbound as they were worried.

 

Wouldn’t it be phenomenal to reduce racism, sexism, and classism down to their basic elements such that we could detect and predict their moves, maneuvers, and operations? Arguably, women, persons of color, and the poor have always done this. Indeed, survival is predicated on these skills, but wouldn’t it be incredible if we did this in a more formalized way, not just to shame the oppressor, but to liberate the oppressed through acknowledgement, predictability, and strategy?

 

At the outset of my Ted Talk, I note that Dmitri Mendeleev (the creator of the periodic table) and I share the same birthday and that we both built algorithms.  He built an algorithm to capture all matter and reduced it down to its most basic elements in order to make those elements known and useful to us. He so understood basic molecular structure that he could predict substances that had yet to be discovered at the time he created the periodic table.  I build algorithms to capture the basic moves, maneuvers, and operations of power as it is raced, classed, sexed, and gendered.  I reduce sexism, racism, and classism down to their most basic constitutive parts in order to make those things knowable for purposes of detection, strategy, and eradication.

 

The Woman Caught In Adultery not only encapsulates the basic ways in which racism, classism, and sexism operate, but it also holds possible keys to liberation. When the rabbi says, “Let those of you without sin cast the first stone,” he sets in motion the cycle of liberation, a calling to all of us: whereby, we rigorously examine our thoughts and actions with a view toward a redistribution of power that gets us closer to ideals of full human flourishing. The rabbi takes the gaze of criminality off the bodies of our Trayvon Martins and shines it on our thinly disguised leaders, problematizing the history of their conduct in a way that renders their attempts to destroy and sexually assault transparent, unconscionable, and condemnable.

 

My Ted Talk challenges us to apprehend Intersectionality, a lesson we might have missed in our popular political movements, but may now explain our current political climate and the possibility for change. Specifically, we learn from the parable that there is nothing new about state violence and police power playing and performing on vulnerable bodies. However, we all have within us, the power to refrain from problematizing and pathologizing vulnerable bodies and to examine critically whether our thoughts and actions advance the cause of full human flourishing. If they do not, at a bare minimum, we can refrain from taking adverse action –a lesson well worth revisiting in a political moment in desperate need of liberation and critical reflection.

 

 

Blanche Cook is an Assistant Professor at Wayne Law in Detroit.  She is a graduate of Vassar College and the University of Michigan Law School.  Prior to joining the academy, she was an Assistant United States Attorney with the Department of Justice, specializing in large-scale drug and sex-trafficking prosecutions.  In the fall of next year, she will be Scholar-in-Residence at the University of California Berkeley School of Law.

This fall, she published Complicit Bias: Sex-Offender Registration as A Penalty for Obstructing Sex-Trafficking Prosecutions. The article chronicles a mistake Congress made in drafting the Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act that requires sex trafficking victims who refuse to cooperate against their assailants to register as sex offenders.  The article is a call to action asking Congress to amend this act of overcriminalization.  Professor Cook also completed a Ted Talk where she built an algorithm to capture power, as it is raced, classed, and gendered, based on the Parable of the Woman Caught in Adultery. 

Advertisements


Categories: Human Rights, intersectionality, Power relations, Race and Ethnicity, racial discrimination, Racism, Sexual Violence, Social Justice, survival

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

11 replies

  1. This is excellent–so concise! Am sure I’ll show this TED talk to my students. Thank you, Blanche, for your contribution to FAR.

    Like

  2. Dr Cook mentions police and state power as elements of the algorithm but not institutionalized religion which conditions, sanctions and upholds them, or rather reflects them. During the pussy hat rally, a black lives matter young man asked if we would be at that rally. I wanted to say without us there would be no lives. This article highlights that intersectionality. As a teacher (woman’s profession) I saw a similar dynamic. Teacher union would support the other unions’ efforts but they would not show up for ours. This imbalance is where intersectionality is challenged to correct the way women support others but do not receive support in return.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. “If, for example, multiple women had accused President Barak Obama of sexual assault and that he had conspired with a foreign country to steal the presidential election, can there be any doubt that we would be embroiled in impeachment proceedings this minute?”

    This says it all.

    Wonderful essay!

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Thank you Blanche. And for the link so I didn’t have to search TED! Going to listen now.

    Like

  5. Thank you, Blanche, for this great article. I will also watch your TED talk, because you clearly have something to teach me. I’m so glad to hear your voice here on FAR. Please come back!

    I was particularly gratified to hear you talk about the lack of the women’s movement to “FULLY embrace intersectionality.” This mitigating adverb is important to me. I taught Women’s Studies in the 1970s at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, and although the word “intersectionality” had yet to come into general parlance, in our classes we taught our students to think about how “racism, sexism, and classism not only overlap, but …support and sustain the work of the other.”

    Like

Please familiarize yourself with our Comment Policy before posting.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: