Why It Matters That Simone Biles Won Times Athlete of the Year Award by Janet Maika’i Rudolph

I remember my first feeling’s of disappointment when Simone Biles pulled out of so many events at the 2021 Olympics. But then I quickly realized that here I was falling for the patriarchal lines that are so much a part of our reality that they become unconscious. Simone Biles taught me. Winning isn’t about slaying your foes (although someone who watches politics here in the US would think so). When Biles withdrew, there were many angry tweets and letters that she wasn’t living up to her promises. Let’s review that. She has been called the GOAT (Greatest Of All Time) of her sport. She is the most decorated gymnast in history. She is only 24. What promise has she broken? To whom? And who are we (meaning the public) to even determine what her promise is?

It is a thing of beauty to watch a gymnast fly through the air, to stick a perfect landing, and do death defying acrobatics. As a society, though, we appear to be unclear about just who they are performing for. Gymnasts are, for the most part, teenagers. They are not Roman Gladiators performing as a blood sport. And yet their bodies are too often treated as such. They are asked to train and perform through physical injury. Their mental health is an afterthought if it is thought of at all.

Simone Biles has conquered more than her fair share. She was in foster care, eventually adopted by her grandparents. She has been a key figure in the Nassar sexual abuse scandal, speaking out publicly, at the trial and in Congress. How could she not need time to heal?

Brava Biles for stepping away. Sunisa Lee, fellow team-mate and gold medalist, said this about Biles; “We all knew we had to continue not without her, but for her. What Simone did changed the way we view our well-being, 100 percent. It showed us that we are more than the sport, that we are human beings who also can have days that are hard. It really humanized us.”

When Biles was named the Times Athlete of the Year (TAOTY), it was in recognition of her contributions not just to her sport but to what it means to be a complete human being. Sports is wonderful, winning can be fun, but if we are expected to lose ourselves in the process, that is a huge problem. And I see it especially as patriarchy issue where a motto has often been “winning isn’t everything. It’s the only thing.”  The fact that Time named her TAOTY, is a huge step to changing that message. Is it enough?

When Biles was interviewed by Time Magazine she said about the Nassar case, “I definitely do think it had an effect. It’s a lot to put on one person. I feel like the guilt should be on them and should not be held over us. They should be feeling this [pain], not me.”

Amen to that. That is a message I have felt as well. Why is it the abused are so often the ones who feel guilt and pain when it is the abusers who have behaved badly? That, to me, is patriarchy in action. The many-decorated Simone Biles makes this point so poignantly.

To round out this discussion, I also wanted to point out the case of Katelyn Ohashi, also wise beyond her years at the age of 24. She was a promising young gymnast who at 15 years old in 2013 beat Biles for the American Cup. This was not a happy moment for her however. She had developed an eating disorder around the age of 14. She competed while her body was in great pain, likely malnourished. She wrote: “My friends and I started getting really self-conscious. We would hear stuff from our coaches. I was told I looked like I swallowed an elephant or a pig, that my face was the size of a balloon . . .We would measure our thighs and if we couldn’t fit our hands around our mid-thighs, then we’d stop eating for the rest of the day. Whenever we’d go to a party where there was a lot of food, we’d feel so bad about eating that we would go to the bathroom and throw up without realizing that’s an eating disorder.”

Even when she was in tears from her pain, the gymnastics federation did not help her seek medical treatment. She had to advocate for herself. Tests revealed that she had been competing with a fractured spine and two torn shoulders. Larry Nassar (yes that Nassar) didn’t want her to have the recommended surgery because it would affect her competitions.

She had the surgery, dropped out of elite competition and went on to join the UCLA collegiate team. One particular thing she wrote holds a special resonance for me: “I’ve said before, ‘gymnastics is abusive,’ but now I know it’s not the sport that’s abusive—it’s the culture that was created and accepted and normalized.” Exactly!

I have come to think of it as the trickle-down theory of patriarchy. What is it about our culture that not only accepts but encourages people to destroy their bodies over an ideal that isn’t healthy, sustainable, or even possible for most? Cheers to Biles and Ohashi for showing us another way. Biles has created her Gold Over American tour. Ohashi has joined it. Biles not only richly deserves her award, she is showing us the way forward. And that is why it matters that she won this award.

You can read Ohashi’s blogposts here: Behind the Madness

And treat yourself to this wonderful, joyful video of Ohashi performing that “broke” the internet in 2019: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ic7RNS4Dfo

Janet Maika’i Rudolph. “IT’S ALL ABOUT THE QUEST.” I have walked the spirit path for over 25 years traveling to sacred sites around the world including Israel to do an Ulpan (Hebrew language studies while working on a Kibbutz), Eleusis and Delphi in Greece, Avebury and Glastonbury in England, Brodgar in Scotland, Machu Picchu in Peru, Teotihuacan in Mexico, and Giza in Egypt. Within these travels, I have participated in numerous shamanic rites and rituals, attended a mystery school based on the ancient Greek model, and studied with shamans around the world. I am twice initiated. The first as a shaman practitioner of a pathway known as Divine Humanity. The second ordination in 2016 was as an Alaka’i (a Hawaiian spiritual guide with Aloha International). I have written three books: When Moses Was a ShamanWhen Eve Was a Goddess, (now available in Spanish, Cuando Eva era una Diosa), and One Gods

Categories: Feminism, General, Patriarchy

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

17 replies

  1. Brava Janet! What Simone Biles did was so important, refusing to turn a blind eye to the abuses suffered by gymnasts and other women athletes. Many will thank her in the future.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Yes, Annelinde, thank you for your comment. I couldn’t agree more. She is a real gamer changer. And while I don’t want to dwell on how young she is (too much) I am beyond amazed. It took me 60 years and longer to find my voice in the face of abuse.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Brava! What brave young heras these female gymnasts are. I’m astonished at what they do –who knew people could fly?? And to compete in gymnastic events with a wounded body? I just shake my head in disbelief at what I’m watching when I see them on TV. (And I have zero interest in men’s sports. I hate football. It’s just men attacking each other.) These young female athletes are graceful and amazing. Thanks for writing about their inner lives and their needs for healing. Bright blessings to all female athletes–be strong, be brave, be resourceful, be proud.

    Liked by 3 people

  3. Oh such a fantastic post Janet and so important for young people especially – These adolescents haven’t even developed an adult brain – how can they not become the sport???? Especially since that is what patriarchy DEMANDS – This woman had the courage to drop out and gave herself a chance to become a person instead of a thing. I know from personal experience having had a brother who was an international runner who broke all kinds of world records as an adolescent – he too dropped out knowing that people didn’t give a damn about him – it was his running that mattered 42 colleges wanted him – Harvard got him – no one cared…. well I sure did but it wasn’t enough…

    Liked by 3 people

  4. This is a wonderful post. I especially love how you connect the experiences of the athletes to the larger context of patriarchy where people are valued not for who they are but for how much they can produce for those who profit off them. I think one reason so many people felt so strongly about Biles was that this is echoed in so many lives, especially women’s lives, when we are expected to work ten hours a day, then come home and do the unpaid work of housework and child and elder care, planning the children’s parties and family vacations, etc., resulting in exhaustion, mental health issues, and more.

    Liked by 4 people

  5. Such astonishingly beautiful young women. How could we have let them down for so long? I am ashamed of the women’s gymnastic hierarchy. I am ashamed of us. And I am so proud of the women who are saying No More!

    Liked by 2 people

  6. Thank you. I stopped watching female athletes (mostly ice skaters and gymnasts) when I learned how they abused their bodies in order to be skinny enough to “win”. But things seem to be changing. I loved the video you posted here. There’s the tennis player who pulled because of harassment by journalists after the tournament. And the female skater who lifted her male partner. Maybe it’s time for me to start watching again.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Judith, if you do start watching again, please give us a report. I will be so interested to see how Biles’ influence affects not only sports but individual athletes. As you point out, there are signs of change happening.



  1. Why It Matters That Simone Biles Won Times Athlete of the Year Award by Janet Maika’i Rudolph – Mama News Sang Haplas
  2. Honoring My Academic Mothers: Carol Christ and bell hooks by Anjeanette LeBoeuf – Social Connections
  3. Honoring My Academic Mothers: Carol Christ and bell hooks by Anjeanette LeBoeuf - Local Cincinnati News

Please familiarize yourself with our Comment Policy before posting.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: