Mazel Tov Tzidkaniyot of the Wall by Ivy Helman

20151004_161012I have never understood the logic behind sexism. Why is half (or so) of the human race better than the other half? Of course, patriarchy and patriarchal religious traditions offer various seemingly logical reasons, sometimes even divine explanations for the inequality between the sexes. Still, the –isms of patriarchy, whatever their “reasons” or perhaps better excuses, puzzle me.

Even more puzzling are the steps patriarchy-orientated men and women take to preserve these distorted systems. Violence usually goes hand-in-hand attempting to control others in order to preserve the status quo. Obviously if you need to resort to violence to keep people in their place, there is something horribly wrong with society. That being said – one could say that almost no society, nation or culture in our modern times doesn’t have some form of patriarchal violence within it. One would be correct to attribute some measure of the increase of violence to globalization, capitalism, fear, past colonialism and/or neocolonialism. Nonetheless one is hard pressed to find a culture without sexism, without patriarchy and without the need to keep the system in place through violence.

Perhaps the most disturbing form of violence is religiously motivated. Yes, religious extremism comes in all forms. The way in which religious theology is perverted to justify killing is wrong, immoral and completely disdainful. Yet, not all religiously motivated violence and pain causes physical death.


The Kotel

Let’s look at one example: the Kotel, or Western Wall. For more than 27 years, the Women of the Wall have had to endure various kinds of physical, emotional and religious abuse from Ultra-Orthodox and (some) Orthodox men (and some women) all because they fight to end various forms of Ultra-Orthodox and Orthodox sexism. They have been belittled as immodest, as disrespectful and as irreligious. They have been verbally harassed, told to wear their tallitot more like scarves and even forcibly carted off by police and arrested. Yet, all they want is an end to the sexist policies at the Kotel and the strict control of its administration by only one stream of Judaism. Yet, they know that with their success, more than just the policies of the Kotel will change.


Rosh Chodesh Heshvan 2013 photo by Miriam Alster

In fact, just last week, Israel announced the creation of a third space at the Kotel. This was the result of negotiations that included the Women of the Wall. The Women write about this outcome saying, “For Women of the Wall, representing religious women from across the Jewish denominational spectrum, the creation of a third section of the Kotel sets a strong precedent in women’s status in Israel: women as administrators of a holy site, women as leaders, women as influential force not to be ignored or silenced… This pluralistic section will provide matching religious services but with ideological diversity, with Torah scrolls, a myriad of choices of prayer books and a strict policy of inclusion, tolerance and acceptance of all who worship there.” This change not only gives women more than just the right to read the Torah publically at the Kotel (which in itself is incredible), but it also impacts the control one interpretation or stream of Judaism has had over religious sites and many government policies in general.

As I wrote many posts ago, religious feminists contribute much to the feminist cause and rather than being written off, they should be acknowledged for the many contributions they have made. In fact, I’m pretty sure it was the Women of the Wall’s understanding of Judaism as justice-seeking, egalitarian and diverse that both enlivened their feminism and motivated their actions.

The Women of the Wall are heroines. In Jewish terminology, we may even call them, and their allies, tzidkaniyot, wise and righteous women who struggle for justice for the oppressed. Their vision of the holiest Jewish site in all of Israel as affirming women and including diverse expressions of Judaism will soon be a reality. We and future generations will benefit from knowing that diversity can thrive and that inclusion is imperative. This is true not just in Judaism but also in larger society. Yet, even before the announcement of this third space, these tzidkaniyot gave hope to thousands of Jewish men and women about the possibilities of egalitarianism, the power of women’s voices and their commitment to making change in spite of the personal cost. They are role models for us all. Thanks to them and thanks to Israel for making this change.

Mazel tov tzidkaniyot!

I can’t imagine what that first Shehecheyanu or blessing will be like there. I look forward to coming and celebrating in the new space with you and saying my own Shehecheyanu there.

Ivy Helman, Ph.D. is feminist scholar and faculty member at Charles University and Anglo-American University in Prague, Czech Republic where she teaches a variety of Jewish Studies and Ecofeminist courses.  She is an Associate of Merrimack College‘s Center for the Study of Jewish-Christian-Muslim Relations and spent many years there as an Adjunct Lecturer in the Religious and Theological Studies Department.  In addition to teaching and research, Ivy spends considerable amounts of time learning Czech, painting, drawing, creating new kosher delicacies and playing with her dog, Mini, and cat, Gabbi.

Categories: Activism, Breaking News, Feminism and Religion, Jewish Feminism, Judaism, Justice, Patriarchy, Sacred Space, Women's Agency, Women's Power, Women's Rights, Women's Voices

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

7 replies

  1. I hail the women and the wall for their perseverance, But sadly the whole deal is built on the illegal occupation of the old city of Jerusalem following the 1967 war against international law. Any comments on the ambiguity of that?

    Liked by 1 person

  2. This is very heartening news Ivy and I wouldn’t have known about it without reading your post, so thank you.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Carol, my understanding of contemporary feminism is that feminists try to find ways to subvert the patriarchal idea of pushing people to be in conflict with each other, and rather finding common dialogue and new, fresh ideas to achieve consensus. Funny not funny that in a post that celebrates a small but significant victory of the liberal streams of Judaism over patriarchal orthodox bigotry, a post about a very refreshing victory, a post that means both for the Israeli and Palestinian liberals a great spark of hope in terms of common sense having more power over animosity and over one-sided interpretation of rules, you chose to point out the conflict that feeds the patriarchal militant anger in that region. Very disappointing.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I cannot understand why the patriarchs of the monotheist religions talk about “modesty” when they engage in oppression of women. Are men never “modest”? Why is hiding hair, face, arms, hands, and body “modest”? And why can’t “immodest” people pray to that god? Does the god feel shame?

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Walter Wink in The Powers That Be (and earlier works) writes of how ancient the oppression of women is (and the oppression of so many of the less powerful). It grows from “taking the spoils of war,” once pack-animals allowed for carrying goods and slaves away after battles. It was a hard book for me to read as he traces this history of oppression. However, he gives a look at how we have been moving constantly toward non-violence and equality of stature as the universe matures. It’s an uphill journey and Wink credits the movement to the radical women-favoring, non-violence-teachings of Jesus, as Wink is a Christian writer. Yet, as I read this blog, I applaud the many voices showing how women and feminists in particular have pursued positive change in a thousand ways. I’m grateful for Carol Christ’s reminder in her comment. It didn’t lessen for me the power of Ivy Hellman’s piece. It reminded me how our steps forward are never “pure”….. While it was a wonderful thing in SOME ways that Jews were able to again find a homeland, that homeland was taken by force and violence. To this day it continues to be tainted by oppression and loss of freedoms and lives. I’m so grateful for all that this blog offers to continue to awaken us to new understandings, and to call us to actions of courage and love. Storyteller, Noa Baum, an Israeli-born, now American storyteller, is doing great work through her performance art and workshops on how to honor and to mend wounds on both sides of this issue. Give her a google.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Thank you, Ivy, for this informative posting. I did not know about this recent change at the Wall! I’m inspired, as you are, to go to Israel and finally be able to pray as a feminist Jew.


Please familiarize yourself with our Comment Policy before posting.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: