Max Dashu’s Witches and Pagans: Women in European Folk Religion 700-1000 challenges the assumption that Europe was fully Christianized within a few short centuries as traditional historians tell us. Most of us were taught not only that Europe became Christian very rapidly, but also that Europeans were more than willing to adopt a new religion that was “superior” to “paganism” in every way. Careful readers of Dashu’s important new work will be challenged to revise their views. When the full 15 volumes of the projected series are in print, historians may be forced to hang their heads in shame. This of course assumes that scholars will read Dashu’s work. More likely they will ignore or dismiss it, but sooner or later–I dare to hope–the truth will out.
History has been written by the victors—in the case of Europe by elite Christian men. These men may have wanted to believe that their views were widely held, but Dashu suggests that they were not. Combing artistic and archaeological records, Dashu finds (to give one example) that images of Mother Earth nursing a snake are far from uncommon and can even be found as illustrations in Christian documents and on Christian monuments. Clerics rage against people—particularly women–who continue to visit holy wells and sacred trees and to practice divination and healing rituals invoking pagan powers. To paraphrase Shakespeare: “Methinks the cleric doth protest too much.” Were these things not happening and happening often, there would have been no need to condemn them. Using these clues, Dashu provides intriguing new readings of the Poetic Edda and Norse sagas.
Reading this book is like opening a box filled with jewels left to you by ancestors you never knew you had. The sheer number of facts and suggestions of facts is overwhelming. Dashu herself is the first to admit that she has not yet put all the pieces together into a new comprehensive her-story of Europe. Still, it is hard to deny that if her work is taken seriously, this is precisely what others will be inspired to do.
For me the most interesting part of this book is the new information about rituals connected to spinning and weaving. I have long known that women were responsible for three inventions that marked humankind’s entry into the Neolithic or New Stone Age. These are the invention of agriculture, the invention of spinning and weaving, and the invention of fired pottery. I have long understood these inventions to involve the discovery of mysteries of transformation: seed into edible plant, wool or flax into thread into cloth, clay into fire into sturdy pot.
Marija Gimbutas’ early work on women’s planting and harvesting ritual songs of her native Lithuania demonstrated that women continued to pass the “secrets” of agriculture from generation to generation for thousands of years. Although I was aware that women’s invention of weaving was remembered in the later Greek tradition of the “Three Fates,” I did not have a clear picture of women passing on the “secrets” of spinning and weaving through ritual and song.
The early chapters of Witches and Pagans fill in this blank. Our European ancestors did not just sit down and get on with the work of spinning and weaving. They invoked female powers–Goddesses, ancestresses, and spirits– when they began to spin and used their distaffs (wooden sticks or poles that held the unspun flax or wool) as divining tools and magic wands. (Here’s an idea: why not replace ritual swords and knives with a distaffs?) Priests castigated women for invoking non-Christian deities while they wove and for tying pagan symbols onto their looms. Once while watching a group of old Greek women carding wool, I was told “our mothers” taught us how to do this. I wish I had asked them if the teaching was via song, for surely it was.
A clearer picture begins to emerge. Women preserved ancient mysteries that celebrated female powers of creativity as they went about the tasks of their daily lives. It was not so easy to stamp these practices out, because women understood their songs and rituals to be essential for the continued flourishing of life.
Thank you, Max for your brilliant work. May it change the way we see the world!
Carol P. Christ’s new book written with Judith Plaskow is Goddess and God in the World: Conversations in Embodied Theology–order now. Ask for a review copy (for blog or print) or exam or desk copy. They are co-editors of Womanspirit Rising and Weaving the Visions. Carol wrote the first Goddess feminist theology, Rebirth of the Goddess and the process feminist theology, She Who Changes.
Listen to Judith and Carol’s first interview on the book on Northern Spirit Radio and their second on WATERtalks.
Carol P. Christ leads the Goddess Pilgrimage to Crete. Space is available on the fall tour October 1-15. Join now and save $150.
14 thoughts on “Weaving and Spinning Women: Witches and Pagans by Max Dashu: Reviewed by Carol P. Christ”
I remember the best and oldest weaver in the Greek medieval village of Mesta on the island Chios once told me that the songs they sang while weaving were guiding the patterns that they wove – it was an integral art of song and weaving created together! I love these beautiful reminders of our deeply connected heritage! Dashu’s book sounds wonderful and I look forward to reading it….
Thanks Cristina for verifying that these songs were still sung in living memory!
Thanks for this, Carol. I love how you wrap arts and crafts and fired pottery into women’s work and the continued flourishing of life. Magnificent thought.
Brava! The author of one brilliant book describing the brilliant book by another author. Hooray! Let us all hope that today’s clerics and historians pay attention to Max’s work.
(BTW, I’m reviewing Max’s book for SageWoman.)
Excellent review of this wonderful and rich book!
Yes! If something was prohibited, then it must have been happening. Sounds like a great book.
I’ve taken a couple of Max’s online classes and have just begun “Witches and Pagans.” Her research and this first of her books is STUFFED with facts and images that make clear that the paganism that predated Christianity in Europe was earth-centered and woman-centered (or at least that women’s participation was essential to the earlier religion). It’s fascinating,
Carol you make a very important point in this review about how worshiping false gods wouldn’t have been necessary if the practices weren’t so prevalent. Of course!
I remember thinking as an adolescent how weird it was that “god”had only been around for two thousand years – I had been indoctrinated into Christian thinking as a child and it never occurred to me to question the spread of Christianity although I resisted the idea that animals had no souls.
After reading this review, I am certainly going to read Max’s book.
I must order Max Dashu’s book!
I must get myself a Russian distaff!
Thanks for the review. Sounds like a “must read”. I can only image the immense effort that must have gone into Max Dashu’s book.
Beautiful and thoughtful. This is a wonderful review of a book that was on my list of future reads but that is now more urgent. Thank you! And of course, thanks to Max Dashu for gifting us with her research and insights.