When Women are Placed on Pedestals to Fall by Cheryl Peterson

Cheryl PetersonWorking alongside my dad on the family farm, I grew up learning how to operate and maintain machinery: tractors, balers, and a double-shift 10-wheeler. We worked outdoors in weather with temperatures ranging from minus 10 to plus 110 degrees Fahrenheit. You could say, I developed a thick skin. Snide comments about me being a girl, doing a man’s job, rolled off.

Dad treated me as an equal, giving me a push out the door of the male-dominated culture that pervades the milieu. But, Dad also protected me from the guys who ogled my abilities. Bluntly said, I learned not to let my achievements be misused by men who wanted a ride.

It wasn’t easy. I sometimes liked the personal attention from the easily impressed guys, but Dad snapped me back to reality. I had work to do, for the sake of the work and for the sake of bettering the world.

I did marry a man in 1983 who respected me rather than worshipped me or my achievements. We’re still married.

My experience on a level playing field has expanded in regard to religion.

I grew up learning about Christian Science, discovered by a 19th century American woman, Mary Baker Eddy. She was a spiritual healer and a prolific writer on the subject of spirituality in healing. Her core book is, Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures.

Despite the outdated references and language in Science and Health, Eddy’s ideas gave me a push out of the human mind’s realities into a divine Mind reality. She wrote, “All is infinite Mind and its infinite manifestation, for God is All-in-all.”

That abstract statement pings me to trust and develop the feeling that there is more to life than what physical senses and human minds tell me.

Though Eddy was a pioneer in human mind study, the clincher for effectiveness was her inclusion of the study of divine Mind. While I learn from science that physical senses are limited and human minds are changeable, I learn from Eddy’s writings that divine Mind is steadily revealing wisdom and healing, to everyone. Like rain on the crops and the weeds.

I learn how to find connectivity between those touching moments when we know we are a part of something greater than meets the eye and when we feel the love that guides us away from marginalizing and isolating any element of humanity.

When fostering children, I reasoned with them that we had the same Father-Mother God even though we may have different human parents. “No one child is better than another child,” I’d tell them.

The children became less fearful, less faultfinding and more peaceful.

Of course, it was the reasoning that was more powerful than my words, as I learned while studying Christian Science. Reasoning is a human faculty that helps us overcome fear and self-doubt so we can sync with infinite Mind’s manifestation.

For this knowledge, I couldn’t help but admire Eddy, and while in my twenties, I surrounded myself with other admirers.

However, while in my thirties, a little red flag of caution began waving, especially when listening to male admirers who piously revered—ogled—Eddy.

It took me years to see that the admiration earmarked Eddy as superior to humanity. It took more years to realize that attitude naturally led to the conclusion that other people are inferior.

The red flag flapped more heartily when two male admirers professed to know what Eddy believed and how Eddy expected people to act today. I fought off the feeling of being unfair to Eddy and entertained the idea that the men’s form of admiration for a woman was a mistake headed straight back to the patriarchal trajectory supported by mass human consciousness.

I didn’t want to follow.

Interestingly, it was Eddy’s critics who veered my mind to reason further. The critics took Eddy’s words out of context, overlooked her achievements and knocked her personality around with accusations of being a cultish leader leading to doom.

Accusations aside, it was the practice of taking words out of context that resonated with the Eddy admirers who based their decisions also on select writings. Was it to support the status quo? To keep their jobs? To purify a religious race? It didn’t matter, what mattered was my response.

Assigning myself to a search mission, I re-read Eddy’s writings to verify that most of what critics and admirers touted had no solid foundation on which to place her.

I also interpreted Eddy’s Science and Health and found the encouragement to continue understanding God and practicing spiritual healing, without human approval or disapproval. I found the inspiration that I could continue to work for the sake of working to better the secular and religious realms. I found I could credit Eddy for her good ideas without crediting her for things she didn’t or couldn’t do.

I found the reasons not to set Eddy or any woman on a pedestal to fall.


Cheryl Petersen is a freelance reporter for three newspapers and a magazine in upstate New York. Her books are: from science & religion to God: A briefer narrative of Mary Baker Eddy’s Science and Health, and 21st Century Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures: A revision and update of Mary Baker Eddy’s Science and Health. She is a columnist online at www.Beliefnet.com Cheryl’s op/ends have been printed in Times Union and Sun Bulletin. She earned a B.S. at Colorado State University.

Categories: Christian Science, Feminism and Religion, General, Patriarchy, Sexism

Tags: , ,

21 replies

  1. My grandmother and her mother converted to Christian Science. I was raised with what I call “the assumption of health.” We rarely went to doctors and rarely got sick. I view this as an inheritance from Mary Baker Eddy. As you describe her view it sounds compatible with say Deepak Chopra.

    Do you know Susan Setta’s essay on Eddy published in Anima? One of my favorite lines from her piece is that Eddy who was raised with a judgmental God said that God must be at least as kind and loving as her own mother.

    Finally, it is amazing how many people still want infallible people and infallible revelations–relieving them of the burden to think things through for themselves.



  2. Interesting. I have not read Susan Setta’s essay on Eddy and will look it up to read for myself. Thank you for telling me about it. I’ve have however, read elsewhere about Eddy’s transition from a judgmental God to a loving motherly God.

    When I myself internalized the kind motherly idea of God, healing was experienced when fostering children. Thinking from the standpoint of one Father-Mother levels the playing field and we can equally feel wanted and loved.


  3. Interesting article. My grandfather was a Christian Scientist…The problem for me is the idea of the mind being split away from the body – privileging mind over body has brought us to the edge of the catastrophic global destruction of Earth – everyone’s Mother, like it or not.


    • There are many views surrounding Christian Science, however, I don’t split the human mind from the human body. I understand them to be one and the same,adaptable to the divine Mind and it’s spiritual manifestation. I strive to adapt to, or evolve into, for a lack of better words, the consciousness of the divine and I think it encompasses a genuine expression of love and care for Earth.
      Thank you for your input and care for Earth.


      • I am glad to hear that. It worries me that unless we actually name the body-mind as one the religious view automatically privileges mind over body… we are all socialized into this kind of thinking.


  4. Interesting blog. Have you also read the works of Horace Quimby, who inspired Eddy? I’ve had Christian Science friends, among other followers of New Thought. In long and interesting conversations with them, I’ve learned that their practice is very much like magic, and their Practitioners think and work a lot like we Witches and Pagans think and work.

    Yes, that pedestal lurks just about everywhere. Let’s all be aware of it. Maybe we can pull it down? Yes, practice thinking for ourselves?


  5. I’ve had no familiarity with Christian Science other than the superficial opinions of others who have no knowledge of Christian Science. I appreciate your post, story, images, which give me much to think about.


  6. Thanks Cheryl, I like that concept of a religion combined with the term science. So I love the name of your faith, because religion and science are supposed to be at loggerheads. And they shouldn’t be at all.

    I love to do nature photography, but to pay the rent and earn a living, I worked for many years on an environmental project. When environmental spirituality arose a number of years ago, that gave me some new perspectives to explore. And I’ve been at it ever since.


    • Sarah, you got me thinking more, about the combination of the terms religion and science. The mix has given me balance. When I catch myself looking deeply for “meaning,” I feel a little lift to also look for “evidence.” They both are valuable on my journey. Thanks for reminding me.


  7. Are not all things already participating in the divine? If creation is the work of the divine, how could anything have been left out to begin with? It’s either a divine creation or a matter of circumstance.


  8. I’d say all creation is the work of the divine, but my understanding of creation is still evolving and I’m concluding that chaos, hate and fear were not created by the divine. Every time I allow anger to participate, it only comes back at me, so I don’t think it ever really participates in the divine.

    Any other thoughts? Good questions, Meg.


    • Hi Cheryl, I can’t separate nature from the divine in my own intuitive understanding. But who knows how it all comes together. Most things need balance to some degree. And so when you say, “every time I allow anger to participate, it only comes back at me,” but the divine may actually be helping you to lower your anger. Anger causes stress and it is not good for the heart, or mental well-being or long life. One way to lower anger is forgiveness, because we all need forgiveness ourselves, at various times, and so because of that, we can more easily forgive when needed.


      • Beautiful, Meg, your thoughts on forgiveness give me more momentum.

        When I mentioned that anger comes back at me, I see that the anger had no ultimate participation in the divine, therefore I’m able to release it as un-created by the divine. And, keeping forgiveness foremost in mind is helpful, thank you.



  1. Guest article | Healing Science Today
  2. When Women are Placed on Pedestals to Fall by Cheryl Peterson #christianscience #marybakereddy | Mary Baker Eddy and Christian Science (Independent)
  3. March 6, 2019 | Christian Science weekly Bible Lessons

Please familiarize yourself with our Comment Policy before posting.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: