” I would say it’s not just patriarchal men in power. The patriarchal women in power are doing plenty of damage as well. The cruel choices are deliberate and to see the pretzels they turn themselves into to justify the cruelty is a sight to behold.”
Janet Rudolph

During the last year I have been repeatedly betrayed by women. In retrospect my mother initiated me into woman betrayal by terrorizing a sensitive little girl by threatening to send her away if she wasn’t ‘good’. My terror of all women and my mother’s skepticism/dismissal of my grandmother as an ‘old woman’ whose opinions didn’t matter eroded my relationship with my grandmother that followed me into adulthood with catastrophic effects.
My fear kept me separate from the comfort of developing friendships with any woman until I became a feminist (yet I felt like an orphan when my grandmother died so my love for her survived).
I came to feminism through the back door through my love for Nature, the only real mother I have ever known. My love for animals, plants, trees, did their best to sustain me although I was very lonely. It is important to acknowledge that I also chose to be alone because I seemed to have so little in common with women in general (my 50 percent).
When I discovered feminism at mid-life, I believed that I was being given a second chance with women. I accepted the mantle of eco -feminism with great enthusiasm beginning with Susan Griffin, Mary Daly, Monica Sjoo etc. – too many second wave feminist scholars to mention. I was also deeply enmeshed in the study of world mythologies, becoming a Jungian pattern analyst in the process. Re- discovering Mary as Goddess set me on a path that culminated in Carol Christ’s and Marija Gimbutas’ work. I had found a home with women at last.
After accruing degrees I taught Women’s Studies at University, became a hospice volunteer, worked at the Abused Women’s Advocacy project and with artists and writers in a Jungian context until I realized that Jungians spent too much time in their heads without attention to body.
I advocated fiercely and tirelessly for feminism and feminists, dedicated to being of service to all women, sculpting images of the goddess, speaking out and writing at first intellectually and later using my own experiences as a woman to uncover what it meant to be a female living in this culture.
Since I have always been an outsider when the second wave of feminism collapsed the acute loneliness returned although I continued to embrace feminism through writing and with friendships with online women friends.
One year ago, on new year’s day, I had a terrifying dream of a wild cat striking in the dark. I had already noted that some patriarchal women were very attached to cats. Cats are predators, secretive, and do strike without warning. I knew from experience having had these animals too. The wild Lynx that appeared outside my window on the second day of January did nothing to ease my fright. My dream and day reality were merging.
Less than three months later, on ‘good’ Friday, Cruella Deville struck with a vengeance. This woman destroyed a friendship of thirty-five years and then having orchestrated the betrayal could not let go. Months later she sent me a lump of coal, which I found ridiculous, even funny having already taken appropriate action, and having let go of this control freak of a woman and her husband who turned out to be a coward. I will continue to hold this woman accountable for her betrayal until it seems no longer necessary. I refuse to wear the ‘victim hood’.
That first monstrous experience was followed by others. With each betrayal I repeatedly owned my 50 percent, dealt with residual anger without striking out, let go, reminding myself that all women were fallible. My position as an eco- feminist remained secure.
I am politically and socially an independent refusing to embrace ideologies of any kind but never considered feminism as an ideology because I am not a radical feminist. I believe most women and men are caught in a 5000 year old patriarchal system that we can’t escape. It’s important to add that I also believe that women and nature have been tarred with the same brush. Woman and Earth abuse are legendary. These are facts not opinion.
I have held this perspective until recently. The last two woman betrayals have been at the hands of feminists in positions of power, one whose friendship I once cherished (the day this betrayal occurred I dreamed that I had been hit by a bright red truck that was also a cat). Each put me over the edge. In both cases I did nothing to bring on such cruelty (no 50 percent). Worse, neither of these women were accountable for their betrayals never uttering a word of acknowledgement or apology – they left me for dead – diminished and invisible.
Struck down with grief I was forced to examine my now troubled relationship to feminism. Maybe I wasn’t a feminist after all? Maybe I had unknowingly adopted a feminist ideology that didn’t include what real women did. Maybe my loyalty was misplaced?
Help arrived almost immediately as two compassionate feminists acknowledged the harm done and stood up for me reversing the feelings of powerlessness and loneliness that flooded me. A third was supportive but took no action on my behalf.
These compassionate caring women gave me a priceless gift – their support which helped me to recover the feminist in me! Any feminist who stands up for another woman is by extension standing up for all of us. What could be more important?
Just after these two betrayals occurred, I found what I thought was an injured wild mourning dove in the grass. Oh, I went to pick up the bird, touched and stroked her before she flew away much to my astonishment. The next night I had exactly the same experience. I have always loved doves and live with telepathic Lily b, a ring-necked dove who is almost 35 so I was on high alert. I had no idea why these wild doves let me touch their silky mole brown feathers with spots and spidery pink legs. but I felt witnessed and cared about by these birds as each stared through me with one beady eye. Weren’t they re-affirming what the compassionate women said and did? I believed so.
Surely the Dove Goddess had manifested to weave my feminist self back into the whole. Each aspect of this multifaceted experience returned my sense of self to me in different ways. I applauded the women’s courage, especially the ones who spoke out on my behalf.
I can now state with conviction that I am an almost eighty-one-year-old feminist who is committed to other women and to the Goddess who loves us all.
‘Mother of Muses, sing for me
Sing of the mountains and the deep dark sea…
Mother of Muses, sing for us all
Mother of Muses, sing for our hearts…
‘Mother of Muses, sing for me
Sing of the mountains and the deep dark sea…
(words adapted from a song by Bob Dylan)
May the Muses sing for us all.
Discover more from Feminism and Religion
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

This post touched my heart.
I am feeling quite alone in my journey.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh dear it sounds like you need a woman centered woman to support you…. you know FAR is such a place and it might help to share? There is nothing worse than that loneliness that comes when one feels she is walking alone.
LikeLike
I have had and lost a few good ones of late. Their paths change or we no longer have time and all that stuff.
I find myself on a path which is requiring slow steady study.
I am also finishing the last book in a trilogy I am writing and publishing and had hoped to discuss these things with the group I once had that I was meeting with. That is no longer a thing so I am going back to square one and asking my spirit guide to show me where I can go.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I do not have a writers support group so I don;t know what it’s like to lose one – but I can still sense your loss – in my life throwing myself on the mercy of nature seems to constellate help that is needed – you are on the right path i think.
LikeLike
I run what is supposed to be a writer’s group it’s on FB and email at groups.io but even there people don’t participate or have discussions anymore.
They’ve forgotten how to do it I think.
LikeLike
What you say disturbs me greatly because something is wrong – really wrong regarding this lack of participation and discussion – we are seeing it on FAR as well – All this junk news – people gravitate towards this kind of stuff but have forgotten how to think? are afraid to think? too ‘busy’ to think, don’t care – I have no idea – it’s like we have gone numb or something.
LikeLike
People have no attention span.
It’s just like I was looking at my comments on my website. A few years ago, when I was first beginning, I had sometimes 12 comments on a post.
Now, it feels like no one is even reading.
I just somehow feel cut off from everything.
Now, don’t get me wrong, a little bit of people goes a ways with me, but I cannot even get people to post in the groups they join. I don’t know why they even sign on.
LikeLike
I first experienced this kind of betrayal as an idealistic young woman when I took my first adult a job working for the spouse of a mentor who worked on the board of a national organization that advocates for women. She got me the job and he turned out to be a career predator. She sided with him. This was my first soul searing awakening that one of ours could be such a hypocrite. Reminds me of that scene in Braveheart where Robert the Bruce is unmasked after subversively betraying William Wallace who is on the ground stunned and defeated. Since then, I have experienced the wolf in the henhouse by women many times. Makes the people true to their integrity, who walk their talk, even more precious to me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah, the wolf in the henhouse – beautiful – says it all – Women who walk their talk – well here’s the hope.
LikeLike
I am sorry you went through this my friend. I have had dealings with patriarchal women in my family’s old church. The idea that even as a teenager, I was more feminist than them still horrifies me now. The things they would justify….
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m ok with what happened because women stood up for me – witnessing makes the difference
LikeLiked by 1 person
True
LikeLike
Humans can be jerks no matter what sex they are. Don’t let that make you give up on feminism.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Blessings on the women who stood up for you. Blessings on you for your clear-eyed commitment to feminism.
LikeLiked by 2 people
As you say – blessings to the women who stood up for me!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Sara. I meant to comment yesterday right after I read your post, which I so appreciated. It’s not easy to write about the betrayals we experience, especially when they happen with people we least expect it to. I am so glad for the witnesses that did speak up – thank goddess! Your post also reminded me of a message I have over my desk: “We can’t place feminism outside the lived reality of women’s lives – not even one individual woman’s life. If we disregard even one woman, one human, we are not embodying feminism.” Your post reminded me of the truth of that message. Thank you!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh WOW Xochitl – I love this statement – I want to copy and use it myself with your permission…all of us need to re-member who we are… betrayals can really throw a wrench into the soup. Those last two almost undid me – but then there is FAR, and Janet, and you – and so many others -it is a bit scary to me that I was THAT undone – but all is well now thanks to women like you! How fortunate your students are to have someone setting an example for us all! love, me
LikeLike