AI: The New Windigo by Beth Bartlett

photo by Beth Bartlett

It was a post about an old growth forest being cut down to build a data center that brought me to my knees in grief. The anguish I’ve been experiencing over the destruction of the planet has been building in me for years, decades even, as I’ve slowly watched the land and water that I love be destroyed bit by bit and at an ever-increasing rate.  So, reading about another forest being devastated and for yet another data center was nothing new, but it was the last in an accumulation of sorrow and rage that left me feeling that I could no longer bear the weight of it. The loss of centuries of growth of arboreal ancestors was shattering in itself, but it was the purpose of this annihilation that ultimately undid me – the new idol that has taken the world by storm – artificial intelligence – the latest iteration of the Windigo[i], destroying the earth and waters in its greed.

Years ago, long before the introduction of AI, one of my students, a computer science major, did his ecofeminism final project on the environmental impact of the internet.  The other students and I were all a bit surprised.  Wasn’t the internet revolution supposed to be better for the environment, reducing the destruction of forests and the need for fossil fuels since we no longer needed so much paper and transportation for books,  newspapers, letters, and other ways to communicate with one another?  No, he warned, because of the vast amounts of electricity and water needed to run data centers. It’s been on my mind ever since.

Data Center, Wikimedia Commons

Now comes AI, with its need not just for data centers, but hyperscale data centers, hundreds of them, thousands, each needing vast amounts of electricity and water. According to a recent UN report, AI-related water consumption alone could equal the basic annual domestic needs of 1.3 billion people by the end of the decade. Date centers pollute the waters with PFAS and nitrates, the air with toxins, the area with heat and light and noise that can be seen and heard for miles. Forests and wetlands and habitats for thousands and millions of beings – from the tiniest microorganisms to deer, bear, wolves, and eagles — are destroyed to accommodate the acreage needed for their construction. 

And for what?  For people to access more information more quickly and ostensibly more accurately?  For machines to do repetitive tasks?  For robots to write students’ papers for them?  For computers to create pieces of music and works of art? For algorithms to tell you who you should vote for? For humans to let their brains atrophy and their analytical and critical thinking skills and their capacities for reflection and discernment and self-expression die off?  For person-to-person connections to be replaced with conversations with Claude? 

Resistance to hyperscale data centers has loomed large in a town neighboring ours where a proposed Google data center would cover over 400 acres and require an estimated 500 megawatts of electricity.  In addition to the noise, light, and heat pollution, the proposed data center would impact the nearby river’s watershed, including its 48 tributaries, 58 acres of wetlands, and the entire St. Louis River watershed which flows directly into Lake Superior and from there to all of the Great Lakes and the Atlantic Ocean. Three quarters of the residents oppose the proposed data center and hundreds showed up at multiple protests, attempting to voice their opposition. The city council kept changing the date for the final hearing before the vote on the proposal and ultimately allowed only a fraction of those who wanted to speak to do so.  Ignoring their constituents, the council voted unanimously for the data center

At the same time, I hear friends and associates blithely talking about how they are using AI for this and that, nothing of any major importance, no groundbreaking discoveries that could save the planet from the tool that discovered them, some of them simply just for fun.  My husband wants to get a bumper sticker that says, “Don’t like data centers? Don’t use AI!”  I told him to get me one, too.  For as much as our digital world has created significant environmental problems, AI does it, as the name of the data centers necessary to support them suggests, at hyperscale. According to the aforementioned UN report, “personal usage accounts for roughly 80 to 90 per cent of total energy demand . . . Generating a single AI image can require more than a thousand times the energy of simple text classification, while video generation demands even greater resources.”[ii]

Reflecting on the outsized love affair that so many have with AI, the words of the first of the Ten Commandments keep coming to mind – “Thou shalt have no other gods before me”[iii] – for it certainly seems that’s what AI has become, a seemingly omniscient and, it is feared, omnipotent deity that so many in the world are worshipping.[iv]

In many ways this seems the logical next step. The other gods the god of the Hebrews feared were Asherah – goddess of the earth, the sea, trees, and motherhood — and her offspring. They sought to replace the immanental divine of the Canaanite people with their transcendent god. For millennia the theology of a transcendent god has contributed to destruction of the earth, for as thealogian Carol Christ warned, a theology that values transcendence over immanence regards the earth simply as a resource for our use and anything associated with it – plants, animals, water, soil, BIPOC people, women – as impediments to the more highly valued spirit, mind, white, Western, male, transcendent god. 

Now what could be more transcendent than an artificial intelligence completely devoid of the body and its wisdom, emotionality, heart, connection with the heartbeat of the earth and its wisdom, and all lifeforms — including humans — on this planet? So, destruction of forests and watersheds and all life on this planet are of little consequence in the worship of this god. Even the warnings within the tech community that AI could evolve into ASI – artificial super intelligence – that could kill all human life has not stopped its rapid expansion and the data centers necessary to power them. Are all of life and the planet itself to be sacrificed in the worship of this new god?

There are those who might see this the destruction as the will of the god who is being displaced by AI — those who extend the theology of transcendence to an eschatological theology that espouses ultimate value to a life beyond this one; that justifies, perhaps even encourages, the destruction of the planet.  But that is not a view that I hold, nor I expect, do most who believe in a Biblical god who looked upon creation and repeatedly “saw that it was good.”[v]

Another way is possible. We can break the hold that AI has on us. With emphasis on the “artificial,” we can recognize it for the artifice, the false god, that it is. “What can stop us,” wrote Carol Christ, “is a deeply felt connection to all beings in the web of life.  What can stop us is that we love this life, this earth, the joy we know in ourselves and other beings enough to find the thought of the end of the earth intolerable.” In her Braiding Sweetgrass, Robin Wall Kimmerer offered a way to defeat the Windigo. “Gratitude,” she wrote, “is a powerful antidote to Windigo psychosis.. . . Gratitude for all the earth has given us lends us courage to turn and face the Windigo that stalks us, to refuse to participate in an economy [and practices] that destroys the beloved earth. . . .”[vi]

With gratitude for those who choose not to participate.

Sources

AI could kill all humans in next decade, warn experts: but how seriously should we take them? | AI (artificial intelligence) | The Guardian

AI’s environmental costs threaten water, land and climate | UN News

Christ, Carol P. The Laughter of Aphrodite: Reflections on a Journey to the Goddess. New York: Harper & Row, 1987.

Christ, Carol P. “Rethinking Theology and Nature.” In Weaving the Visions: New Patterns in Feminist Spirituality. ed. Judith Plaskow & Carol P. Christ. New York: HarperOne, 1989: 314-325.

Holy Bible. Revised Standard Version.

Kimmerer, Robin Wall. Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge, and the Teachings of Plants. Minneapolis: Milkweed Press, 2013.

Sensitive brook trout habitat identified near proposed Hermantown data center | Quetico Superior Wilderness News


[i] The Windigo is the legendary monster of the Anishinaabe people.  Robin Wall Kimmerer tells of how Windigos are cannibals and anyone they bite will become cannibal monsters, too.  “The more a Windigo eats, the more ravenous it becomes. It shrieks with its craving, its mind a torture of unmet want. . . . The Windigo is the name for that within us which cares more for its own survival than anything else.” Braiding Sweetgrass, 304-305.

[ii] AI’s environmental costs threaten water, land and climate | UN News

[iii] Exodus 20:3. RSV.

[iv] I recently heard anecdotally that even ministers are using AI to generate sermons and I know of at least one instance in which it was used to create a song for a funeral.

[v] Genesis 1, RSV.

[vi] Kimmerer, Braiding Sweetgrass, 377.


Discover more from Feminism and Religion

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Beth Bartlett

Elizabeth Ann Bartlett, Ph.D., is an educator, author, activist, and spiritual companion. She is Professor Emerita of Women, Gender, and Sexuality Studies at the University of Minnesota-Duluth, where she helped co-found the Women’s Studies program in the early 80s. She taught courses ranging from feminist and political thought to religion and spirituality; ecofeminism; nonviolence, war and peace; and women and law. She is the author of numerous books and articles, including "Journey of the Heart: Spiritual Insights on the Road to a Transplant"; "Rebellious Feminism: Camus’s Ethic of Rebellion and Feminist Thought"; and "Making Waves: Grassroots Feminism in Duluth and Superior." She is trained in both Somatic Experiencing® and Indigenous Focusing-Oriented trauma therapy, and offers these healing modalities through her spiritual direction practice. She has been active in feminist, peace and justice, indigenous rights, and climate justice movements and has been a committed advocate for the water protectors. You can find more about her work and writing at https://www.bethbartlettduluth.com/

4 thoughts on “AI: The New Windigo by Beth Bartlett”

  1. Thank you for writing this, it is sorely needed right now and a stark reminder of how dangerous these data centers are! Increasingly, we are being forced to use AI in situations where it’s not always obvious, such as chat support bots on a website, for example; many of these companies make it increasingly harder to telephone them with support questions.

    Like

  2. Thanks for this important post, Beth. I was amazed at the statistic you give that 80-90% of AI is personal use. I had no idea. As Melissa notes, it is harder and harder to not participate because AI is now so embedded in activities of daily living. That makes it even better and more important to take walks in the woods, cook a homemade meal, spend time chatting with friends – no AI needed! And all these ways of spending our time result in gratitude, for nature’s beauty, for the bounty nature gives us, for the joy of being with each other.

    Like

  3. Thank you for this timely sobering post. I have found, am finding it hard to resist looking things up often about plants and birds and how to care for my garden. What a horrifying irony that this habit/addiction is so destructive of the things I love best.

    Like

  4. Beth, you are on a roll with your most excellent posts… Thank you for trying to educate – my heart goes out to you in your grief – I will repost this essay on my blog. It is hard for me to understand how people are so easily duped except when I recognize that people WANT or NEED to be. I have reached the point in my own life where a lifetime of OBSERVING has brought me not just to my knees but rolling around on bare ground – I can no longer write about the atrocities you speak of. I named our reliance on machines the rise of the ‘MACHINE GODS’ MORE THAN THIRTY FIVE YEARS AGO AS MOUNTAINS WERE BEING SHORN OF THEIR TREES BY DIRTY YELLOW MACHINES. When I first came here I thought I had found paradise but my dreams knew better – I was peering over the edge of Catastrophe as all the mountains were being stripped of their trees in my dreams while whole forests remained intact around me …BUT NOT FOR LONG. I think and feel that I have been living through this tree /earth GRIEF from the beginning of this round of time and didn’t know it, and that now we are moving into the last stages… – today my dreams show me the Wasteland that lies ahead. I have been advocating for trees, animals, an Earth as an eco feminist long before I knew I was one- When I realized that a lifetime of effort wasn’t enough I thought I could let go but it was not to be. I will never accept that this was meant to happen – it’s a CHOICE we westerners have been making for a very long time often unconsciously out of personal/socio/political need ( this goes deeper than blaming patriarchy). We are all culpable and we would do better to root out the ways we are responsible…. I can no longer write about machines or the takeover of AI – to me it was inevitable part of the ugly story that some of us have been forced to live through encroaching AWARENESS and realizing that we are the problem – As Deena Metzger writes “We are AI” … We need to face it -people are in love with their machines – not as a tool but as our latest ‘god’. Someone I deeply respect said to me the other day ‘AI has already taken over – there’s nothing we can do’. Well, maybe not, but someone in me believes that going along with this atrocity regardless of outcome is ethically and morally wrong. Will it matter? Our protesting/ along with accountability matters – I don’t pretend to know how.

    Like

Login to your WordPress account to facilitate your comment submission, https://wordpress.com/log-in/ and please also familiarize yourself with our Comment Policy before posting.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *