Two Madonnas, From Grief to Grace by Carolyn Lee Boyd

Sweet Madonna from my childhood

When I was ten, my grandmother bought me a small red faux-ivory Madonna statue from a cart outside the Vatican. The young woman depicted is sweet and pious, with her hands together in prayer. For decades the statue was the only connection to the Madonna and her maternal Divinity I possessed. To be honest, I did not think much about it as I grew up. It was mostly a remembrance of my grandmother’s love, compassion, and kindness. The statue still sits above my desk.

Then, fifteen years ago, I was getting ready to leave my office in an old Victorian building and go home. I was muttering to myself about feeling edgy all day because it was the anniversary of a bad car accident. Then the heavy wooden outer door opened, then slammed. An instant later, the inner door also flew open with a bang. A nun, perhaps 75 years old, in a full-length gray habit, burst in asking directions to the nearest highway. I told her which road to take and she was gone.

The Black Madonna of Częstochowa

Then slam! Bang! She returned holding a plastic bag full of hundreds of tiny medals depicting the Black Madonna of Częstochowa, the spiritual force of the 1980s Polish worker’s movement and an inspiration to millions of followers over many centuries. The nun handed a medal to me saying “Here. This will protect you” and disappeared again into the twilight.

For weeks afterwards I pondered. How did the nun end up at my off-the-beaten-path workplace at that hour? Why did she bring in the medals since it is unlikely she heard me complaining about the car crash through two sets of heavy wooden doors? And why was I, the most ordinary of beings, chosen to be part of this baffling, mysterious incident?

I began to keep my medal in my wallet as a magical talisman to prevent me from experiencing misfortune. Mostly I forgot it was there. I had never been one for sending requests for favors up to heaven, or, indeed, communicating directly with Divinity much at all. If Divinity was really Divine, should Divinity not already know what was in my heart?

The Madonna, like any good mother, gives her children exactly what they need, even if it is not what they want or expect. When I was diagnosed with cancer a couple of years later, medical opinion was mixed on whether my diagnosis was dire or hopeful. Suddenly, requests for intercession from any readily available spiritual being made more sense. It was as if the medal was like a silent prayer wheel sending unending pleas for help up to the Madonna. Please let me grow old among family and friends. Please let me see my son graduate from college. Please let me have more summers of verdant abundance in my garden and winters of cozy Saturday afternoons in our little Victorian house.

For five years I kept the medal in my wallet, through recovery from surgery, many rounds of chemotherapy, and many more radiation treatments. Then, quite unexpectedly, my oncologist told me that a new test showed that I had a tumor marker indicating that relapse was unlikely and, if I had one, there was now a very effective immunotherapy. And, I did not just have a normal amount of the marker, but a veritable Niagara Falls of the marker. Aha! All those prayers had finally been answered.

During those years, I somehow overlooked the contradiction that my diagnosis itself was the kind of calamity from which I was hoping the medal would spare me. Still, the nun had, to be honest, been rather vague about what I was actually being protected against. I should have listened to that ambiguity.

This past year, two very dear friends died tragically within a couple of months of one another. An overwhelming abundance of grief grew in my belly and soon became a burgeoning question of faith. Protection for me but not for my friends? What were prayers to the Madonna worth if she was playing favorites?

The Madonna, like any good mother, gives her children exactly what they need, even if it is not what they want or expect. By pondering this question of why I am alive and my friends are not, I first came to begin to understand that the convolutions of destiny and divine intervention are not subject to my comprehension. My cancer was the result of a drug my mother took before my birth to prevent miscarriage. If my mother had not taken the drug I would never have had cancer. But she might also have miscarried me and I might never have been born. Perhaps wishing Our Lady had changed my friends’ destiny was not only unfair, but unwise and such individualized intercessions are not only what the nun meant by “protect.”

Recently, it seems the tragedies across the globe just seem to keep piling up— climate catastrophe, pandemics, natural disasters, violence, war—and no medals can keep the effects of all this from devastating everyone’s well being. I was forced out of my old ways of thinking and began to ponder new questions.

I thought back to the little red Madonna of my childhood with her hands in the prayer pose. Never once in the almost sixty years since I received that statue have I ever wondered who she was praying to. After all, weren’t we supposed to be praying to her? And why is the Black Madonna of Częstochowa on the medal looking straight at me with that expression of “Didn’t I tell you to do something? Have you done it yet?” What if both my little red Madonna and the Black Madonna, are praying to us, demanding all of us, to be the answers to each other’s prayers? What if they are telling us to rush into creaky old buildings with bags of medals, or into a home of the bereaved with a casserole, or onto a park bench to provide companionship to a stranger when needed? Or to offer water to a thirsty motherwort plant, to pass a law to protect an endangered species, or to build a nesting platform for loons? To bring to our actions the Madonna’s immense love, compassion, and wisdom of the Divine?

Perhaps“This will protect you” meant that it will protect me against apathy, despair, self-doubt, and fear when the time comes for me to act? Wouldn’t that be something?

Mothers always know what their children need, but also what they are capable of. So, it seems that we can, each in our own way, be the hands of the Madonna, or whoever’s voice each of us hears when the Earth and those who live on her are in pain, to bring grace from grief in this troubled world if we so choose.

And so now I sit with my two Madonnas and keep the knowledge handy that we are here to lead the next generation to a better Earth than we have known, even if many of us may never live to see it. What would you have me do today?, I ask. What prayers for the Earth and those who dwell on her need answering now? When I was younger, I needed the sweet, uncomplicated image of the Madonna of my red statue to begin my journey towards the maternal Divine. Now that I am older, I feel the rage, misery, and hope of the Black Madonna of Częstochowa. The Madonna, like any good mother, gives her children exactly what they need at the time, even if it is not what they want or expect. From grief to grace, we are the answer to our prayers and hers.

Photo credits:

Sweet red Madonna (c) Carolyn Lee Boyd, 2026

Black Madonna of Częstochowa, Public Domain


Discover more from Feminism and Religion

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Carolyn Lee Boyd

Carolyn Lee Boyd has been writing about the sacred in everyday life and the wisdom of being in community for over 40 years. She has published fiction, essays, and poetry about feminism, women’s spirituality, and art in print and online periodicals including Women Artists News, SageWoman, Feminism and Religion, Return to Mago, Matrifocus, The Beltane Papers, We’ Moon, and more. Her work is seasoned by her decades-long human services career in which she got to know the life stories of a diversity of extraordinary “ordinary” women. She would love for you to visit her at her website, www.goddessinateapot.com, where you can read and download some of her previously published work as well as a little music.

Login to your WordPress account to facilitate your comment submission, https://wordpress.com/log-in/ and please also familiarize yourself with our Comment Policy before posting.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *